Talk:Robert McNaughton: Difference between revisions
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
| (One intermediate revision by one other user not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
Patrick wrote: | |||
The person who edited this page to say that this Robert McNaughton is not the same person who wrote the score to "Henry: Portrait of a Serial Killer" mis-read Paul Zamost's message from the Chicago Punk Pix board. Robert McNaughton wrote the music, John McNaughton directed it. Some believed that the 2 were brothers or relatives. They are not, that is what Paul's message was saying. | The person who edited this page to say that this Robert McNaughton is not the same person who wrote the score to "Henry: Portrait of a Serial Killer" mis-read Paul Zamost's message from the Chicago Punk Pix board. Robert McNaughton wrote the music, John McNaughton directed it. Some believed that the 2 were brothers or relatives. They are not, that is what Paul's message was saying. | ||
Galanter responds: | |||
I went back and checked and you seem to be right. I misread the somewhat confusing dispute. To clarify, Zamost seems to be saying (1) Robert *did* write the score (2) he *didn't* rip it off and (3) despite the same last name he is unrelated to the director. | |||
Thanks for setting me and this entry straight! | |||
: I am on the same page here - [[Paul Zamost|Zamost]] said that he did write it, didn't steal it and wasn't related to the director. Almost made a thread about it on [[CPP]] but kudos to Patrick/Galanter for using the discussion section! A handy tip for talk pages - if you use four tildes (~) at the end of a talk paragraph, it subs in your login name and the current date/time. And a colon at the beginning of a line will tab it in, a good way to signify that a reply on the discussion page is a response to the paragraph above it. Very handy for long discussions. - [[User:Gantry|Gantry]] 09:17, 15 June 2007 (CDT) | |||
Latest revision as of 14:17, 15 June 2007
Patrick wrote:
The person who edited this page to say that this Robert McNaughton is not the same person who wrote the score to "Henry: Portrait of a Serial Killer" mis-read Paul Zamost's message from the Chicago Punk Pix board. Robert McNaughton wrote the music, John McNaughton directed it. Some believed that the 2 were brothers or relatives. They are not, that is what Paul's message was saying.
Galanter responds:
I went back and checked and you seem to be right. I misread the somewhat confusing dispute. To clarify, Zamost seems to be saying (1) Robert *did* write the score (2) he *didn't* rip it off and (3) despite the same last name he is unrelated to the director.
Thanks for setting me and this entry straight!
- I am on the same page here - Zamost said that he did write it, didn't steal it and wasn't related to the director. Almost made a thread about it on CPP but kudos to Patrick/Galanter for using the discussion section! A handy tip for talk pages - if you use four tildes (~) at the end of a talk paragraph, it subs in your login name and the current date/time. And a colon at the beginning of a line will tab it in, a good way to signify that a reply on the discussion page is a response to the paragraph above it. Very handy for long discussions. - Gantry 09:17, 15 June 2007 (CDT)